top of page

Beyond Airbnb: could a private villa be your next favorite vacation?

Nov 4
4 min read


Somebody always ends up doing the dishes


Every family has one: the person who plans the reunion, books the house, writes the grocery list, and somehow ends up scrubbing a lasagna pan at 10 p.m. while everyone else is in the pool. (If you just pictured yourself, this article is for you.)


When families or friends travel together, most people head online, straight to Airbnb or VRBO. That's a perfectly good place to start, and I book those kinds of vacation homes for clients all the time. I also book private villas, which a lot of people don't realize is an option. My job is to figure out which one fits your group, and I'll always tell you honestly, even when the answer is the less expensive

choice.




What's the difference between a vacation rental and a villa?

The main difference between a vacation rental and a private villa is how the home is run. A vacation rental is usually managed by its owner or a local host, while a villa from a professional villa company often comes with staff, housekeeping, and a concierge. (Plenty of villas show up on Airbnb and VRBO too.)


Some vacation rental hosts go above and beyond. Others hand you a door code and wish you luck.


I book villas only through reputable villa companies I’ve vetted, ones that inspect their homes and take care of my clients. Depending on the home, the help might include daily housekeeping, a cook, groceries stocked before you arrive, and a concierge who books your airport transportation, a boat day, and dinner reservations.


And no, every villa isn't a St. Barts mansion with a butler named Reginald. Plenty are a comfortable farmhouse in Tuscany or a three-bedroom place near the beach in Mexico, where you bring in a chef for one big dinner and cook the rest yourself. There are even small villas made for two, which are lovely for an anniversary.


There's lots of overlap. Some VRBO homes offer nearly everything a villa does, and some villas are pretty basic. That's why I compare the actual homes, not the labels.



Same trip, two ways


These are examples, not quotes. Prices and amenities change with the season and the home.


Three generations in the Dominican Republic. 

A big vacation rental in Punta Cana gives everyone room, a pool, and a kitchen. It also gives someone a full-time job running that kitchen. At some villas in Casa de Campo and Punta Cana, a cook and a housekeeper come with the house. Grandma and Grandpa get a quiet breakfast on the terrace, the kids are in the pool by 8 a.m., and dinner shows up without anyone herding 12 people into a restaurant.


Two families in Punta Mita, Mexico. 

With a vacation rental, your first sightseeing stop is the grocery store, along with everyone else who just landed. With a villa, a driver meets you, the fridge is already stocked from your list, and your first stop is the pool.


Three couples in Tuscany. 

A charming farmhouse rental is a lovely home base, and I can line up drivers and day trips around it. A villa might add a local cook who teaches a pasta class in your own kitchen. Same rolling hills, same long dinners, fewer arguments about who has to drive those narrow country roads. (Many Tuscan homes rent Saturday to Saturday in summer, so plan ahead.)



Is a private villa more expensive than an Airbnb?

Villas can be expensive. They can also surprise you. Say four couples split an $8,000 villa for a week. That's $2,000 per couple, or about $286 a night, which can compare well with four upscale hotel rooms. And you get a kitchen, a living room, and a pool to yourselves.

Add taxes, deposits, groceries, staff gratuities, and extra services, and the math can change. Sometimes the villa wins. Sometimes the vacation rental or a hotel does. I'll lay out the full cost of each so you're comparing apples to apples.


What I check so you don't have to

  • The beds. "Sleeps 12" might mean four king rooms and two bunk rooms. Great for cousins. Less great for six couples.

  • The stairs. A hillside villa with 40 steps down to the pool looks amazing in photos. Grandpa's knees may disagree.

  • The location. A spectacular view can come with a 20-minute drive to the beach.

  • What's included. Housekeeping days, a cook, pool heating, transfers. I'd rather you know now than be surprised at check-out.

  • The fine print. Deposits, cancellation rules, and minimum stays. The best homes for holidays can book up a year ahead.


My honest take


I'll always point you to the option that fits your trip best, and I'm not going to recommend a pricier option just because it has a fancy name. For a couple spending three nights in Paris, I'll suggest a hotel. For a family out exploring all day who just needs a comfy place to sleep, a vacation rental is usually perfect. If you want the restaurants, entertainment, and kids' clubs of an all-inclusive resort, a villa probably isn't your best choice. For a reunion, a milestone birthday, or three generations under one roof, I'll show you some villas too.



What everyone remembers

Years from now, nobody will remember whether the kitchen counters were granite or marble. They'll remember the cousins' cannonball contest, the dinners that ran late because nobody had to get up and clean, and Grandpa telling the same story for the twelfth time while everyone laughed anyway.


And this time, the person who planned it all was sitting at the table too.


Barbara is the owner of Suite Dreams Travel in Layton, Utah, and has more than 20 years of experience planning trips for families, couples, and groups.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page